So it is a rant.
At the start, SET FOR SET is a bodybuilding and fitness company that prides itself on delivering awesome information that’s backed by science while also noting any nuances that will occur. There’s numerous false information on the market and it’s our mission to weed out all of the nonsense and provide you with what’s real.
So we very much are a part of the “science-backed” movement occurring within the fitness community.
Nonetheless, has this movement of being “research-backed” gone too far? This has been an ever growing problem on the planet of fitness that I even have noticed ever because it was coined back within the day.
The Origins of ‘Science-Backed’ Fitness
At first, this realization that we could use science to enhance our workouts was awesome! Depending how old you’re, you could not realize that it wasn’t that way back when the concept of “research backed” didn’t exist.
Throughout the 90’s, you principally got your info out of your buddy on the gym or a slew of fitness magazines that were owned and pushed by different complement firms! Also, you never questioned anything! If someone larger than you gave you advice, you’d simply follow it.
The Rise of Exercise Science
Exercise science was in its infancy in addition to our knowledge. I mean, it was also at the moment that eggs were demonized, creatine was said to be a steroid and there was still a little bit of fear that lifting weights would make you muscle sure!
Luckily, researchers eventually began to take lifting weights seriously and commenced to check it from a science viewpoint. Exercise science exploded, as did our understanding of the human body, and these findings would find its way into the load room. This trend grew and grew until it reached the purpose we’re at now.
The Youtube Era and Its Impact
After which Youtube stepped into the equation. Youtube was great since it was the primary time regular people could easily go browsing and get fitness information from people all around the globe. Unfortunately, at first, much of the content was just people giving their opinions and attempting to sell you something.
To combat this, the “research-backed” movement fought back. Content creators began making some extent to present information that was backed up by science. Not did people simply give their opinions. In case you said something, you’d have research to back it up. Obviously this existed on a spectrum but you get the purpose.
Amazing.
But then something happened. Everyone watching these fitness videos became experts and scientists (in their very own head). Regular viewers began to present their interpretation of a study they once saw once but would share it as fact.
When given advice, you’re met with the query, “Do you’ve got a study to back that up?” which is then inevitably followed up by, “I need to see it. Where’s the research?!”
You get the concept.
The rise in research isn’t a nasty thing in any respect. Some firms, comparable to SET FOR SET, have been in a position to use exercise science to offer solid information so that you could see higher results.
Nonetheless, for all of the “good sites” there’s dozens of people who find themselves using “research” incorrectly. Want an example? I got you!
Earlier this week, a man posted a study on pre-sleep protein in a Facebook group.
Pre-sleep protein has numerous research to back its use so it’s solid information.
Nonetheless, a girl randomly asked “What in regards to the heart problem?” People repeatedly asked her what she was talking about and she or he claimed eating food at night causes heart problems.
She posted a couple of different studies and articles to back her up so I checked them out. One article specifically spoke of eating a great quantity of junk food throughout the night, not 200 calories of fresh casein.
In the opposite article, the writer literally states that while there are a few studies suggesting this is perhaps a difficulty, it’s almost certainly not an issue, especially for lively individuals. So she principally just read the title of the article.
I pointed this out and she or he continued insisting it was bad because she saw one other study. She then asked me “Where’s your study that claims it doesn’t cause problems?”
You see where that is going.
The Problem with Over-Reliance on Research
On this case, the issue is that individuals have latched onto an idea they think is backed by research yet misinterpreted the findings. In addition they cling to individual studies that appeal to them yet they rarely read the study anyhow nor consider that one study doesn’t prove anything. Either way, they could be easily misled.
One other problem is those that demand to see a study before they do an exercise or follow a program to prove it really works. Of their minds, if there’s no study, it doesn’t help. Or in the event that they can’t see a study, it must not be effective. You’ll be able to easily see the flaw on this.
The Value of Practical Experience
Remember once I stated that back within the 90s, people were just getting advice from their buddies? Well, guess what—they were getting jacked! Your complete Golden Age of bodybuilding lasted from the 60s to the 80s, though exercise science was hardly a thing!
There are many examples that show bodybuilders were following methods that were later found to be legit within the lab, comparable to the mind-muscle connection.
The purpose is that a study doesn’t validate a response seen within the gym. If coaches have been seeing a certain exercise or rep scheme constantly produce awesome results, why need a study!?
I can inform you that I definitely do things that research would suggest I don’t. Why?
Well, because I see measurable results, and it really works for me. At the identical time, if I even have a client who’s doing something that goes against research, yet they enjoy it and it really works for them, I won’t tell them to stop!
We’d like to understand that while exercise science has exploded, there continues to be plenty we don’t know and our understandings are continuously changing. In that very same breath, there’s all the time the individuality that have to be considered.
In case you ever checked out a study, I mean really have a look at one and examine the findings, you’ll see that the outcomes have a fantastic amount of variation. So while there could also be a trend towards a selected finding, it’s never 100%.
Heck, I’ve seen studies where a selected workout helped burn more fat than one other. Nonetheless, once I checked out the small print, I noticed that a number of the people actually gained fat. The purpose is that research in exercise science only shows trends. Something to think about.
Yet one more issue is those that use science incorrectly to mislead people and earn cash. A first-rate example: EPOC (Excess Post-Exercise Oxygen Consumption, aka the afterburn effect)! I’m sure you’ve seen a gym or trainer saying “we’ve found a secret fat burner…” or “my program is predicated on the newest research…”
First, EPOC has all the time existed. Even after we didn’t have a reputation for it, people still saw the consequences of it in the event that they trained hard, you simply didn’t understand it. All we did with research was discover it existed and put a reputation on it.
The claims of its effectiveness are wildly exaggerated. This could be very common. Research is totally misused as a method to sell something. And since we live in a world now where people “love science”, people love to listen to it!
Conclusion: Finding the Middle Ground
My essential point is that quality training uses a mixture of research backed studies in addition to experience which is then mixed in with personal preferences. Every little thing you do doesn’t should be backed up by science nor does it must; that is assuming you’ve got some rationale for doing it.
At the identical time, don’t buy into every thing that claims it’s backed by science. The term has been hijacked and thrown around a lot, it barely even means anything anymore. Plus, you should utilize an exercise even when there is no science to back up its use! If it really works, it really works!
And most significantly, just be consistent along with your training. Keep attending to the gym and training hard!
Find the proper workout plan for you in under 60 seconds.
